BlameThePixel!

BTForum » BlameTheOffTopic Forums » BlameTheGeneralOffTopic » American and English Comedy

Poll: What'll it be?
American 3 users
English 7 users
Abstain 3 votes
(13 votes have been cast so far)Can't Vote While Logged Out!

Page: [1] [] [3]
[]Zippy
Strange
Send PM
An Avatar
Posts: 2033
Threads: 147
Mood: Paranoid
Money: £3733.51 (D)
Inc. Tax: 10%
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour



I've been pondering on making this thread for a long time but zomg, it's here.

Which comedy will do y' go for? I see a 50% on both of them, but if just had to choose one. American. I don't have a huge opinion on English because I haven't seen to much of it. I've seen Benny Hill, and very little of Monty Python.

American comedy can fall sometimes under "stupid humor". Don't know what I mean? Try this or this. And English comedy, I ain't too good on explaining that.

________________
02.08.06 14:47
Post #1
[Hide Sig (11)] [Profile] [Quote]
[S]Bloopy
Lazy, Busy, Fizzy, Crazy
Send PM
An Avatar
Posts: 2996
Threads: 145
WA Clan: WwA
Money: £764.65 (D)
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour
Sure I like some of the American humour and enjoy shows like South Park, Malcolm In The Middle, and That 70s Show. Complete Savages was a recent good one but that only lasted 1 season. However, some American comedies I just find boring.

On the other hand most of my favourite shows are British comedy... Shooting Stars, Harry Enfield, The Young Ones, Father Ted. It's so crazy and funny, it's got cult appeal. I guess I would describe British comedy as "ludicrous humour".

________________

Quoted :: Bloopy

Quoted :: thomasp
I suppose that's one "good" thing about my degree (aero engineering), there aren't too many terms/words/etc that have "alternative" meanings.
What, like cockpits, turboshafts, thrust, nozzles, corkscrews, ram drag, payload, flaps, and wind tunnels?
02.08.06 21:35
Post #2
[Planet Bloopy] [Hide Sig (7)] [Profile] [Quote]
[]Spleet
Looking For Status
Send PM
Posts: 1279
Threads: 73
Money: £374.42 (D)
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour
I like all kind of comedy.. I have seen a fair share of Monty Python. On the other hand, what you would call, "American Comedy", I would say that some of it is good, and then some of it is just dull, or boring. Alot of it gets old fast as well.

I look at it this way.. If I happen to see something on TV, that I think may be funny, I leave it on. But most of the time it is very, very dull.
02.08.06 22:31
Post #3
[Hide Sig (3)] [Profile] [Quote]
[ES]Pioneer322
Orangie Orgy
Send PM
An Avatar
Posts: 2375
Threads: 38
Mood: FFFFFFFFFFF
Money: £1289.13 (D)
User Tax: -322%
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour
What I hate about it here in the U.S. is the censorship policies. Its nuts... FCC can just go uck themselfs

They sensor hole in asshole, anything slightly violent or sexually suggestive... or even just suggestive gets debated on whether or not its good to air or at what time

They can make good comedy sometimes but.. it gets predictable/censored/taken out of air/dull

meh

edit: oh and i havent seen any 'english' comedy HOOO
02.08.06 22:52
Post #4
Last edited: 02.08.06 22:53 (Pioneer322 - 1 times) [Hide Sig (2)] [Profile] [Quote]
[]TheAbdBoy
Single
Send PM
Posts: 4158
Threads: 322
Money: £1844.11 (D)
User Tax: -99%
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour
English, they have a real sense of humour.

read boot_error.

________________
03.08.06 05:30
Post #5
[Twitter] [Hide Sig (0)] [Profile] [Quote]
[S]Zogger!
Looking For Status
Send PM
Posts: 3954
Threads: 62
Money: £93.82 (D)
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour
paramount comedy is one of the more boring channels for most of the day... There's about 20 random american sit-coms with very bad laugh tracks and the most predictable jokes ever.
Meanwhile I believe a lot of british comedy with laughing is actaully done for real - even if it's not, at least it's not overdone.

There is some good american stuff, and you can't really just sum up british comedy in those few programs.. but.. yeh..

________________
You know I'm a dancing machine
03.08.06 09:08
Post #6
[Hide Sig (8)] [Profile] [Quote]
[]RunT
Statusless
Send PM
Posts: 2600
Threads: 106
Money: £29.56 (D)
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour
Best of British Comedy:
1. Boot_Error
2. Lee Evans
3. Little Britian
4. Monty Python
5. Dad's Army

________________


03.08.06 11:24
Post #7
[Hide Sig (10)] [Profile] [Quote]
[]Zippy
Strange
Send PM
An Avatar
Posts: 2033
Threads: 147
Mood: Paranoid
Money: £3733.51 (D)
Inc. Tax: 10%
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour



I may be an idiot for saying this. But sometimes, the censorship can make things funnier, but only with some words. If someone specifcally says "A-hole" and all you hear is the A (A... Not ass) then it's fucking stupid. But when someone says fuck and you hear just the "F" I just find that too hilarious. But they put good movies on comedy central, and they censor the balls out of it, like Scary Movie 2 and Not Another Teen Movie, they ruined those movies. Why don't they just put those movies on the stash? When they do that to movies like Joe Dirt and Kingpin it's not so bad, but still...

As for the comedy bit, English comedy can go on for so long and still be funny, it travels a long road without dying. As for American, it's a bit harder, and you have to think up fresh stuff all the time. When I watch movies like 40-Year-Old-Virgin I just get blown away by the clever things they added in there. And it's more of American shows that die due to the "unfunniness" all the time. Like... Friends... Or the ever queer blowing "That 80's show!"

________________
03.08.06 12:52
Post #8
[Hide Sig (11)] [Profile] [Quote]
[]Star Worms
Rats Sworm
Send PM
An Avatar
Posts: 1527
Threads: 44
WA Clan: WrU
WWP Clan: WrU
Mood: Bored
Money: £3968.69 (D)
Inc. Tax: 10%
User Tax: -15%
Ttl. Tax: -5%
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour




Don't forget Ab fab, Vicar of Dibley, One foot in the grave, Open all Hours. There must be loads more of great comedy shows that haven't been mentioned.

________________
04.08.06 04:13
Post #9
[RealVG] [Hide Sig (11)] [Profile] [Quote]
[]Psymon
RAAAAAAUUUUUY!
Send PM
Posts: 2671
Threads: 130
Money: £202.97 (D)
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour
Anything English before (I'm talking sitcoms here) Open All Hours is apsolute harilious, anything after (My Hero, My Family and many more) suck so many balls, the only exception is "The IT Crowd", which I thought was funny...
We've also only had one funny sketch show, Goodness Grasious Me, everything since has been apsolute shite (EG: Little Britain, Cathrine Tate, The Fast Show)

America has produced a lot of stellar sitcoms like Becker (currently showing on Five, which is good. I missed it from the Comedy Central) and The Drew Carey Show (which hasn't been shown over here and isin't on DVD :() But it also puts out a lot of crap, filler sitcoms that are ok, but never that great.
As far as I know, America only has one sketch show, Whose Line Is It Anyway? which is consistantly great!

________________
Photobucket
04.08.06 09:52
Post #10
[Hide Sig (14)] [Profile] [Quote]
[]The Pope
Decisive
Send PM
An Avatar
Posts: 5183
Threads: 123
Mood: Refreshed
Money: £201.52 (D)
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour
Haha, nice to hear you consider b_e british comedy, Runt and Abd :P

If I had to choose between the two, I'd go with British comedy without a doubt. Indeed, apart from Little Britain and Catherine Tate Show, I can't think of a single comedy I wouldn't mind watching that has come out here. Some of my favourite shows are Black Books, Green Wing, Nevermind the Buzzcocks, Have I Got News For You, classic Mr Bean and Whose Line Is It, which you yanks stole :P

________________
Learn to look, look to learn.
04.08.06 10:24
Post #11
[Hide Sig (14)] [Profile] [Quote]
[S]ReadMe
Absent
Send PM
Posts: 2820
Threads: 85
Money: £43.42 (D)
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour
The formulaic american sitcoms that get churned out and shown over here on abc1 and paramount are genernally terrible - but there are a few that push their heads above the cloud, Scrubs and Familty Guy are up there with my favourite comedies ever.

There have been some british comedies that are as appalling as the majority of the american ones - that one with davina McCall in was a good example, cant remember the name now. There's been a lot of good stuff though, and i dont recall ever seeing an american comedy quiz show.

Like zog said - you cant really judge the many by the few, but on the whole i much prefer the british style of humour - the american sitcoms tend to be too obivous with the gags.

________________
Cant be arsed to remake my sig.
04.08.06 14:18
Post #12
[Hide Sig (7)] [Profile] [Quote]
[]RunT
Statusless
Send PM
Posts: 2600
Threads: 106
Money: £29.56 (D)
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour

Quoted :: ReadMe

The formulaic american sitcoms that get churned out and shown over here on abc1 and paramount are genernally terrible - but there are a few that push their heads above the cloud, Scrubs and Family Guy are up there with my favourite comedies ever.


What about Home Improvement? Thats generally a funny show to watch. Different material nearly every show.
Which is kinda good I suppose because it keeps me interested, instead of the same thing but in a different way.

In this instance, I'd like to remove 'Little Britian' from my list in the previous post, and replace it with 'Porrige' or 'The Two Ronnies'. :)

________________


04.08.06 20:17
Post #13
[Hide Sig (10)] [Profile] [Quote]
[]Zippy
Strange
Send PM
An Avatar
Posts: 2033
Threads: 147
Mood: Paranoid
Money: £3733.51 (D)
Inc. Tax: 10%
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour



Another thing I hate is when a show (usually Amercian) comes out and it runs for so long, so many seasons and such, when the show just obviously isn't funny. It's like there not making jokes, it's like they say things and you hear random unneeded laughter from the audience because something directs them to laugh. Yet the show just lives on. Perfect example, the Chris Rock Show.

________________
06.08.06 08:07
Post #14
[Hide Sig (11)] [Profile] [Quote]
[S]Zogger!
Looking For Status
Send PM
Posts: 3954
Threads: 62
Money: £93.82 (D)
(+ Friend)
Not online within the last half an hour

Quoted :: Zippy

it's like they say things and you hear random unneeded laughter from the audience because something directs them to laugh.


The play button on the laugh track...?

________________
You know I'm a dancing machine
06.08.06 10:39
Post #15
[Hide Sig (8)] [Profile] [Quote]
Page: [1] [] [3]

Post Reply

Jump To:


Your Comments:

Donate to BlameThePixel:
Donate to BTP Via PayPal


[22 Queries, Page Loaded in 0.262295 Seconds]

ShoutMeUp

Xmas Greetings from waka waka waka waka []Unvalidated EmailChristmasRiddle MERRY CHRISTMAS EVERYONE! []Spleet Except for Spleet. []TheAbdBoy Always bummin' a brother out. []Spleet Happy New Year everyone! But Spleet. []TheAbdBoy

Word Association

All

-10 Ago-

MiddleEastern []AlphaWolf camel [S]Bloopy toe []TheAbdBoy moose knuckle [S]Bloopy MeatLoaf []Spleet IdDoAnything4Lo ve []AlphaWolf rub n tug []TheAbdBoy tugboat []The Pope rope [S]Bloopy race []TheAbdBoy

-Latest-


Must be logged in to add new words

FictoLeague

You have to be logged in to vote...

Member Stats

Date: 21.11.24.
Members: 4731.
Latest: []Unvalidated Emailsdsakldsaldklasdsdsa
Active:
0 user(s)
1 guest(s)

On chat:
Lots of people

Files: 3330

Bloopy's Site
Get Firefox Get Opera Donate to BTP Via PayPal